Subscribe to Waco Trib XML RSS Feed E-Newsletter WacoTrib on your PDA
Register Now.  It's Free!  |  Log In
Classifieds
Wacotrib Cars
Real Estate
Employment
Merchandise
OPINION
Editorials| Letters to the Editor | Archives | Blogs


Carlos Sanchez: That's not journalism

Sunday, March 02, 2008

West Mayor Jerrel Bolton told the Trib he was embarrassed for his community last week after a nationally televised news program shined a spotlight on anti-Muslim racism in Central Texas.

I have to say to Mayor Bolton that I am embarrassed for my profession.

Broadcast on a television news magazine, moderated by a journalist and produced by the news division of ABC, the show, “Primetime: What Would You Do?” may have been entertaining. It may have been engrossing, perhaps even a little illuminating.

But it certainly wasn’t journalism.

In the program, reporter John Quinones, a journalist I long have admired, set up a series of staged events intended to provoke a reaction among passers-by and records on hidden camera just how they react.

One segment shows both a man and a woman actor parallel parking and slamming into a parked car, literally knocking its bumper off. Then the actor declares to witnesses that he or she is too busy and walks off without addressing the damaged vehicle.

In another segment, strollers in a park become witnesses to three teen-aged girls taunting and bullying a fourth girl.

Hidden cameras in West bakery

In the segment that so enraged Mayor Bolton, hidden cameras were set up in West’s Czech Stop bakery to capture reactions to an actor portraying himself as an employee who is refusing service to a Muslim woman while demeaning her faith.

Using imprecise language in the local segment, the staged event broadly indicts much of Central Texas by simply describing the location of the racist one-act play as a roadside bakery outside of Waco.

Although each segment includes some psychologist providing color commentary about human behavior, viewers are left to wonder: what are we to conclude by this behavior?

That people leave the scenes of accidents? That there are bullies and racists in this world? Or that we are good or bad depending on how we confront these situations?

To be sure, some heroic moments were captured on the hidden cameras, especially in West when the Rev. Charles R. Holm-Roesler stood up to the actor portraying a clerk and defended the Muslim.

Those were genuine tears he shed later when the hidden cameras were revealed to proclaim him a decent person.

But journalism is about informing, not manipulating.

Admittedly, the Trib got caught up in it, too, when we found out that West was going to be featured in a nationally televised segment and we ran a large front-page story about this last Monday.

Had I seen the ABC segment before we ran our story, I would have challenged the play of our story.

Just like NBC’s “To Catch A Predator,” in which journalists set up Internet sex sting operations in cooperation with police, I do not believe what ABC did is journalism.

Indeed, in one of the most blatant instances of racism that ABC’s cameras captured, it then masked the identity of the offender.

By using actors to create a story where none existed, by lacking the courage to show on TV the most blatant example of racism that it captured on its hidden cameras, ABC effectively left viewers with exactly the wrong impression.

So instead of exposing that racist for what he is, ABC protected the man. He becomes a symbol for a community. Our community.

The viewer is left with an impression that such overt racism is commonplace in Central Texas and Waco, the only city named.

If anything, the problem with racism in society today is that it is much more subtle than a generation ago, certainly more subtle than ABC depicted.

That’s not journalism.

Mayor Bolton told the Trib that he would like to see ABC apologize to West.

I doubt he’ll ever see such an apology. So I will take it upon myself to apologize on behalf of all journalists who take offense with this electronic voyeurism and call it journalism.

Carlos Sanchez’s column appears Sunday. You may contact him at 757-5703. E-mail: csanchez@wacotrib.com.

Comments

By Roger Powell

Mar 4, 2008 1:30 PM | Link to this

Thanks, Carlos Sanchez, for writing this revealing story about how "yellow" journalism is becoming. I, myself, enjoyed my High School Journalism classes and clubs at Waco High (circa 1968-70). My teachers and mentors TAUGHT us what Yellow Journalism was and I am thankful for it.

I believe that you, Mr. Sanchez, stood up not only for Central Texas by exposing these staged stories, but for Journalism, too.
Thanks again, Carlos.

By bigyaz

Mar 4, 2008 11:44 AM | Link to this

First, who ever said that these prime-time TV shows were journalism? As a journalist, I reject that notion.

Second, I find it fascinating how the tables turn when the subject of one of these shows is a local community. Suddenly all the snap judgments one might have made about the people involved (if it had happened, in, say, Florida) get turned around: "This isn't representative of our community." "You can't judge us by a few people." "This was contrived, a setup."

Remember that next time you watch one of these shows.

By 91Bear

Mar 3, 2008 11:18 PM | Link to this

The tragic events at Mt. Carmel took place on from Feb. 28 through Apr. 19, 1993. I doubt ABC was even thinking about something that happened 15 years ago.

By cfk

Mar 3, 2008 8:53 PM | Link to this

Where is the outrage from the Muslim community from the Muslim attack on us?

Was it a bakery worker in West who flew missles into the twin towers? Was it the cook at the West Kolache house that was filmed dancing in the streets in utter glee, at the sight of the Twin Towers coming down?

We didn't have an anti-Muslim sentiment in our great land until MUSLIMS attacked us.

The reason we are at war is because of radical MUSLIM extremists, who want us exterminated.

Wake up people. Smell the napalm. What do you want to do with these animals, bring them home and keep them as pets? Let them babysit your kids?

These people are 13th century barbarians, who would rather cut your grandchilds throat, than live. THATS WHAT THEIR BIBLE TELLS THEM TO DO.
DAMNN

By Greg Yorick

Mar 3, 2008 7:17 PM | Link to this

It's sad to see how the networks have lowered themselves to Fox-style journalism. I wish that there a US TV network devoted to covering the real news of the world instead of wallowing in the mud and focusing on ill-informed opinions, but such a thing no longer exists. Aside from The NewsHour with Jim Lehrer and various CSPAN programs, I can't think of a single American news program that hasn't been "infected."

By Judy Bolton Long

Mar 2, 2008 4:49 PM | Link to this

This was a left wing action and ABC should be ashamed of trying to stir up this kind of trouble. Nothing good can come from this kind of electronic voyeurism.

By null

Mar 2, 2008 8:59 AM | Link to this

By the way, do you think it was an accident that ABC aired this segment just a day or two before the anniversary of the tragic events at Mt. Carmel? I think not. In my opinion it was a deliberate attempt to incite the country against this area again.

Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.

Post a comment



Remember me?

You may use the following formatting:
Bold: **this text will be bolded** = this text will be bolded
Italic: *this text will be italic* = this text will be italic
Link: [text to be linked](http://www.wacotrib.com) = text to be linked



There will be a delay of up to 5 minutes before your comment appears.


*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.

 
Waco Tribune-Herald Top Cars
Driver Air Bag|Passenger Air Bag|Passenger Air Bag On/Off Switch|Side Head ......(more)
Intermittent Wipers|Power Steering|Four Wheel Drive|Adjustable Steering Whe......(more)
Driver Air Bag|Passenger Air Bag|A/C|AM/FM Stereo|CD Player|Front Disc/Rear......(more)
Split Bench Seat|Intermittent Wipers|Power Steering|Dual Zone A/C|Adjustabl......(more)
Chevrolet Silverado 1500, 2003, 5.3L V8 SFI, Standard Pickup Truck...(more)
Power Passenger Mirror|Power Steering|Variable Speed Intermittent Wipers|Pa......(more)
Tires - Rear All-Season|Variable Speed Intermittent Wipers|Driver Air Bag|C......(more)
Chevrolet Suburban, 2003, 5.3L V8 16V, Special Purpose Vehicle...(more)
Chevrolet Silverado 2500HD, 2003, 6.0L V8 16V MPFI OHV, Standard Pickup Truck...(more)
Nissan Altima, 2006, 2.5L I4 SMPI, Midsize Car...(more)
-View All Top Cars-
-Place an Ad-
 

Wacotrib News | Wacotrib Weather | Sports | Living | Business News | Wacotrib Schools | Opinions | Baylor Football
Wacotrib Cars | Wacotrib Real Estate | Wacotrib Jobs | Classifieds | Sitemap

Copyright 2008 Waco Tribune-Herald. All rights reserved. - The Waco Tribune-Herald - Our Partners

By using this service, you accept the terms of our visitor agreement and privacy policy.
Registered site users, you may edit your profile.
Having trouble? Visit our help & FAQ.