For the past three years, McLennan County commissioners have budgeted for an average of $6.1 million more than the county spent, but local leaders say that’s a big improvement to years past.

Commissioners reviewed the overbudgeting as they started to wind down discussions of the proposed budget for fiscal year 2018, which starts Oct. 1.

Some of the commissioners said they have trimmed requests for more money than needed for specific purposes as they have worked through requests in the past few weeks. Others said $6 million in unused funds equates to about four cents on the tax rate that is collected and goes unused.

All the commissioners agreed budget padding has decreased in recent years.

The county’s four road and bridge departments, managed by commissioners, have had at least $1 million combined in unspent money budgeted for them in each of the past three years — more than any other part of the budget.

Residents need to be getting something in return for their tax payments, and the fact that commissioners’ road and bridge departments are the worst offenders is concerning, Precinct 3 Commissioner Will Jones said.

“All these other elected officials and some department heads come in and say, ‘Oh I’m giving money back to the budget.’ Yeah, you are giving it back to the fund balance but not the tax payer,” Jones said. “I think we’re doing a good job. We’re in a lot better shape than we were. But we just need to be as efficient as we possibly can. Tax dollars are so precious.”

The county’s budget is projected to have $5,497,575 left over by Sept. 30, the end of this fiscal year. There was $6,281,916 unspent in fiscal year 2016 and $6,539,933 unspent in 2015.

More than $2.1 million of the unspent money this year will come from road and bridge departments. About $3.2 million came from road and bridge in 2016, and $3.1 million came from road and bridge in 2015.

Jones said the unspent money, to him, is one more argument against the county keeping 33 percent of its projected expenditures in a fund balance in case of an emergency. Commissioners last year agreed to move past its 25 percent fund balance, which had been in place for years, to 29.23 percent of annual expenditures. County Judge Scott Felton is pushing for the county to reach 33 percent.

The proposed fiscal year 2018 budget includes a $32.46 million in the projected ending fund balance, or 30.96 percent of total expenditures.

Jones said the county should stick to a fund balance that is 25 percent of total expenditures.

County Judge Scott Felton said the county should be more skillful at handling its budget than having $6 million remaining at the end of the year demonstrates.

County Auditor Stan Chambers said several factors came into play. The fiscal year 2017 budget started with a beginning fund balance that was $4 million higher than anticipated, he said. Expenditures were also not what was anticipated during the current fiscal year and revenues were higher than projected, he said.

“We want to be conservative,” Chambers said. “I do estimate the revenues conservatively, but I don’t believe overly conservative.”

Precinct 4 Commissioner Ben Perry said when he was elected, each commissioner had an about $2 million contingency for each road and bridge department. The elected leaders have since paired that down to $250,000, he said. Perry said he would support eliminating road and bridge contingency completely.

“If we get into a pickle of any kind we can always go to the general fund,” Perry said.

The culture on the commissioners court needs to change so it is not taboo for a commission to ask for additional funding when there’s an emergency, like a bridge collapsing, Perry said.

He said the commissioners should have started discussions of this nature at the beginning of budget discussions, not toward the end.

The sheriff’s office’s budget will likely always have a relatively high amount of leftover money at the end of the year because its personnel positions are rarely all full, Perry said. The sheriff’s office budget is predicted to have more than $966,000 left over at the end of fiscal year 2017.

“They’re budgeted to be fully staffed, but they have a hard time staying fully staffed,” Perry said.

Some leftover money is acceptable, he said. Expenditures can never be predicted exactly.

“We have to hold ourselves accountable like we do everyone else,” Perry said.

Precinct 1 Commissioner Kelly Snell said it’s better for the county to be under budget than over.

Snell said the county used to have contingencies in every department, but only the road and bridge contingency budgets remain.

“I don’t think you’ll ever get it where you’ll be at zero at the end of the year, but I can tell you right now it’s a lot closer than it’s ever been before,” he said.

Road and bridge overbudgeting by precinct

Source: McLennan County

  Budget Actual spending Amount spent
FY 2015
R&B Pct 1 2,792,037 2,552,136 239,901
R&B Pct 2 2,659,777 2,223,134 436,643
R&B Pct 3 2,278,928 1,772,590 506,338
R&B Pct 4 3,323,270 2,576,871 746,399
R&B (countywide) 1,168,733 9,788 1,158,945
FY 2016
R&B Pct 1 2,894,383 2,516,919 377,464
R&B Pct 2 2,736,226 2,310,602 425,624
R&B Pct 3 2,523,030 1,962,719 560,311
R&B Pct 4 3,303,643 2,100,808 1,202,835
R&B (countywide) 646,654 17,027 629,627
FY 2017 (projections) (projections)
R&B Pct 1 2,962,073 2,607,927 354,146
R&B Pct 2 2,827,596 2,178,244 649,352
R&B Pct 3 2,598,286 2,404,753 193,533
R&B Pct 4 3,366,398 2,797,584 568,814
R&B (countywide) 363,174 1,898 361,276

Three-year review of overbudgeting by department

Function Budget Actual spending Amount unspent
2015
General Government 23,958,457 22,379,884 1,578,573
Judicial 6,290,013 5,835,730 454,283
Public Safety 28,750,007 27,767,069 982,938
Public Transportation 12,462,915 9,372,167 3,090,748
Health 7,286,049 7,221,260 64,789
Welfare 5,848,942 5,745,064 103,878
Culture/Recreation 131,093 76,483 54,610
Conservation 247,836 228,893 18,943
Economic Development 1,589,466 1,398,299 191,167
Debt Service 1,135,332 1,135,328 4
Totals 87,700,110 81,160,177 6,539,933
2016
General Government 24,389,517 22,927,792 1,461,725
Judicial 6,528,110 5,895,176 632,934
Public Safety 30,260,917 29,571,236 689,681
Public Transportation 12,345,453 9,140,109 3,205,344
Health 7,550,312 7,429,632 120,680
Welfare 6,443,014 6,336,682 106,332
Culture/Recreation 28,843 22,093 6,750
Conservation 256,329 233,634 22,695
Economic Development 1,898,451 1,898,449 2
Debt Service 4,899,803 4,864,030 35,773
Totals 94,600,749 88,318,833 6,281,916
2017 (projections) (projections)
General Government 25,043,373 23,602,712 1,440,661
Judicial 6,861,928 6,371,158 490,770
Public Safety 32,577,237 31,610,552 966,685
Public Transportation 12,382,821 10,235,729 2,147,092
Health 7,542,813 7,448,534 94,279
Welfare 6,804,276 6,619,280 184,996
Culture/Recreation 35,066 29,221 5,845
Conservation 263,973 237,410 26,563
Economic Development 2,254,373 2,113,733 140,640
Debt Service 3,025,120 3,025,084 36
Totals 96,790,980 91,293,413 5,497,567

Cassie L. Smith has covered county government for the Tribune-Herald since June 2014. She previously worked as a reporter for the Beaumont Enterprise and The Eagle in Bryan-College Station. Smith graduated from the University of Texas at Arlington.

Recommended for you