Sunday, December 07, 2008
By J.B. Smith
Tribune-Herald staff writer
Consider the pretzellike life cycle of the public water supply. Water is pumped from reservoirs and aquifers, treated to drinking standards and piped to people who spray it on their lawns.
Or it’s fouled in kitchens, toilets and showers, then transported many more miles to be treated again and dumped in the river.
This system may be sanitary and convenient, but it’s also wasteful in a state where growth is bumping up against limited water supply.
That’s why McLennan County cities are beginning to explore ways to squeeze the most out of every drop of water.
City of Hewitt officials, facing limitations on water supply and sewer capacity, are discussing the possibility of requiring “graywater” reuse systems in new homes. That means diverting water from washing machines and showers to separate plumbing that will irrigate the lawn.
Meanwhile, the Waco Metropolitan Area Regional Sewer System, which includes Waco and its suburbs, is planning to resell millions of gallons of treated wastewater for nonpotable water uses, starting with a coal-fired power plant now under construction in Riesel. Dynegy is expected to pay up to $750,000 a year for sewer effluent from the main WMARSS plant on the Brazos River.
Hewitt: No sewer crisis yet
This August, Hewitt officials sounded the alarm: The wastewater system was strained to the point that the bedroom community might have to put a moratorium on homebuilding.
The alarm may have been premature. Monitoring at sewer lift stations over the last few months has shown that the system isn’t as close to capacity as officials feared, said community services director Paul Holroyd.
“The sky is not falling, at least not this week,” he said. “We know we’re going to come upon a critical situation, but it’s not happening nearly as fast as we thought.”
Hewitt’s growth in recent years has put extra demand on the transmission pipes and lift stations that connect it to the Waco Metropolitan Area Regional Sewer System. Hewitt officials had hoped a new sewer plant at Bull Hide Creek would allow them to divert waste in a different direction to take the pressure off, but that project is likely to be held up by the opposition of Bull Hide Creek neighbors.
Holroyd said Hewitt needs a Plan B in case that project drags out. That could include pumping sewage into a tank during the day and releasing into the system at night. But he said the slowdown in the housing market may reduce the urgency to expand the system’s capacity.
“I’d say we’re probably OK for a year or so,” he said.
WMARSS officials are considering spending up to $6 million next year to pipe water from the main sewer plant on the Brazos back upstream on Flat Creek to be used for golf courses or factories.
And the regional system is hoping in coming years to divert up to 600,000 gallons a day of treated sewer effluent from the proposed Bull Hide Creek plant near Lorena.
“What we’re doing and what Hewitt is looking at doing helps us meet our water demand through the state’s 2060 water planning horizon,” said Waco Assistant City Manager Wiley Stem. “We have to figure out ways to use water in a way that we can sustain it given our limited supply. That means we’re going to have to use water differently than how we use it now.”
Cut in consumer use
State water planners are counting on consumers to reduce their use of water in coming decades, partly by installing more efficient appliances and irrigation systems.
The State Legislature in 2003 also made it easier for consumers to use some of their water twice through graywater systems. State rules now allow homeowners to discharge up to 400 gallons a day of water from showers, baths, bathroom sinks and washing machines onto yards. The water has to be strained and cannot be allowed to pool. It can’t be sprayed on the lawn, and homeowners must be able to divert the graywater stream back into a sewer or septic system.
Officials with the Texas Commission on Environmental Quality and the city of Waco said they haven’t seen a rush of people installing such systems.
But Hewitt community services director Paul Holroyd said the city of Hewitt is considering requiring them in new homes, complete with a storage tank, a pump and separate plumbing. He estimated that the systems could cost about $2,000, though he said more research is needed.
He said the system would benefit Hewitt and individual homeowners. It would take strain off Hewitt’s city wells, especially in the peak summer months. It also would divert wastewater from sewer pipes and lift stations, which have been under strain. And in the long run, it would save residents money.
“We’re still in the headscratching stage,” Holroyd said. “The city council has discussed it some, but the staff will have to develop it before it goes to council for a decision. . . . I don’t know whether we’ll eventually adopt that kind of measure, but people today are much more environmentally conscious than in the past, and this is a good way to save money.”
He said he and most other Hewitt residents have concrete foundations, which are impractical to retrofit for graywater systems.
“If I could do it tomorrow at my house, I’d do it,” he said.
Eddie Wilcut, conservation manager for the San Antonio Water System, said he’s not aware of any cities in the U.S. that require dual plumbing for graywater, though it would be a good idea.
He said such a system might save a family of three about 120 gallons a day, which might not be enough to justify the expense of storing and pumping the water.
Still, he said plumbing new houses for graywater would be a forward-looking step in a state where water is becoming scarce.
“If we’re really serious as a state or a country, we need to start dual plumbing in every house we build today,” he said.
‘Purple pipe’ system
In the meantime, he said San Antonio has become a leader in water conservation through low-flow appliances and better irrigation practices. While its population has increased 50 percent since the 1980s, overall water consumption has remained steady in the city, which relies on limited groundwater supplies.
He said part of San Antonio’s conservation strategy was treating and reusing wastewater. The city installed a “purple pipe” system — the pipe color indicates that the water is nonpotable — to serve industrial and irrigation users and to keep the San Antonio River full. The water sells for one-fourth the cost of regular drinking water.
Waco also is awakening to the value of its treated effluent, said Stem, the Waco assistant city manager.
He said some cities are selling effluent for 70 percent of the cost of regular water, but he would like to sell it cheaper to maximize its use. He said the majority of the effluent from Bull Hide Creek could be sold to users in Lorena, Hewitt and other communities.
Meanwhile, engineers are studying the feasibility of adding a “purple pipe” system as part of a 2009 project to pipe sewage to the main WMARSS plant from Interstate 35 between Loop 340 and Sun Valley Boulevard.
The purple pipe carrying the treated effluent would parallel the main 42-inch-wide sewer interceptor line but would flow the opposite direction, from the sewer plant toward the Texas Central Industrial Park.
“If we can capture that water at the treatment plant, we’re really making the most efficient use of our water,” Stem said.
jbsmith@wacotrib.com
757-5752







Comments
By j.b. smith
Dec 8, 2008 7:14 PM | Link to this
Ron,
The city officials I talked to said the city doesn't have rules against graywater use. In that case, as I understand, state laws apply. The TCEQ works with the EPA and can't approve rules that conflict with federal laws. But it's definitely not legal to allow your graywater to run off your property.
By Big Ron
Dec 8, 2008 4:43 PM | Link to this
I hate to bring this to 'all' of your Attention; But local Laws do 'not' allow or permit a person to use potable(sinks,showers/washing machine) water on their yards. And regardless of State Laws, the Federal Government(E.P.A.) DOES NOT ALLOW THIS EITHER!!! And 'All' water winds up back in the Brazos or Bosque Rivers, or other Rivers to go on downstream for others to Treat/Filter for Public drinking water!! And Bottled water is still Tap water, and even Dr Pepper is made with Tap water in it!!!!!!! But I'll agree that We need to Conserve our Water somehow!!!! Now can we spit on the sidewalk downtown??????
By j.b. smith
Dec 8, 2008 1:15 PM | Link to this
To clarify: Lorena is buying 320,000 gallons of sewer capacity a day from the Waco Metropolitan Area Regional Sewer System. The town currently has a capacity of 150,000 gallons. Also, Bull Hide Creek effluent would not be sold to the coal plant in Riesel but to users in the Hewitt and Lorena areas.
By Pat Kultgen
Dec 8, 2008 11:04 AM | Link to this
It is not cost efficient to pump treated effluent from Lorena to Reisel, yet this is what is included in the permit-effluent will be used for industrial coolant. The citizens of Lorena have been told this plant is essential for growth, yet they are only purchasing 150,000 gallons per day. This is exactly what they have now, and they have exceeded the state limits! According to their loan from the Texas Water Development Board, they can use the millions to expand their current facility to 400,000 gallons per day, or use it to send their 150,000 gpd to the Bull Hide site, which is miles away. In addition, they have paid Waco 385,000 dollars to take their existing plant, but have to bring it into compliance first! Now, add to that the cost of paying Waco to manage the plant and you have to ask, what is going on?
By Large Marge
Dec 8, 2008 8:49 AM | Link to this
I'm happy to hear that my effluent water goes to Lorena. I hope they guzzle it down. That town is nothing but an I-35 speed trap. I don't speed, but every time I drive through there I see 15 officers lining the highway shooting for speeders. That's why I don't buy anything in Lorena.
By Fred
Dec 8, 2008 8:11 AM | Link to this
All of the waterways of Slaughterhouse Waco and McLennan County are polluted.....Lake Waco, the Bosque River and the Brazos River. To Hell with your polluted Water.......I buy and drink bottled water and Dr. Pepper.
By qzy
Dec 7, 2008 11:08 AM | Link to this
I gotta agree with Not Fred. It tastes like we are already drinking gray water. If yours tastes like aquarium water, then you're lucky.
By Not Fred
Dec 7, 2008 9:53 AM | Link to this
From the smell and taste of the water that comes out of the faucets at my house, I'd say they are totally bypassing the treatment plant. My ice taste like it was made from an aquarium.
By Estaven
Dec 7, 2008 9:29 AM | Link to this
It's about freaking time. Taxpayers have been asking for this capability and other sustainable measures for over a decade. The time has long since past that politicians and bureaucrats can take taxpayer funds to finance their own pet projects and line their own pockets. The next steps to take are implementation of rain water collection and wholesale adoption of renewable energy. Get on with it!
Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.
Post a comment
*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.