Thursday, June 18, 2009
Water is an efficient conveyor of sound. At a peaceful, four-star hotel pool, even more so.
Recently, in a departure from workaday toils at an education conference, I experienced at poolside how the nonworkaday world lives, and thinks.
Two suntanners, who definitely are not fans of our president, were talking health care policy. Both appeared alarmed at the prospect of change — though not frantic enough to change their bodily positions.
“They want what Canada has,” said one.
“I hear Canadians come over here for procedures,” said the other. “Where do we go if Canada’s system comes here?”
Ducking my head under the chlorinated cool, I’d heard enough. It doesn’t take long to hear it all from one side of the debate about health coverage. Basically, its members have health coverage, and that’s enough.
Barack Obama is promoting a Canada-style health care system, they say. Yep. And he is converting the Washington National Cathedral into a juice bar.
Agreed, Obama covets the end result Canada has achieved — health coverage for everybody. But only a person addled with overexposure to sun, or to right-wing talk radio or Fox Spews, would compare his way to Canada’s.
Public-private contrivance
Obama seeks to create a hybrid in which government picks up where private enterprise poops out — 45 million Americans without health insurance.
So doing, he angers many on the left who advocate a single-payer system.
Bill Clinton’s venture into this minefield had some of the same elements of intrigue and public-private intermarriage. Battered by the insurance industry, it ultimately fell under the weight of Rube Goldberg-style complexity.
Obamacare portends to be simpler, building on tried-and-true concepts like the Children’s Health Insurance Program.
Those who spit nails as they deride this as socialist medicine will be seen swallowing their scruples soon enough when Medicare eases their health care dilemmas in retirement.
For Obama, the dilemma is getting enough votes, even in a Democrat-controlled Congress, to resolve that we won’t continue to have increasing numbers of Americans among the uninsured.
We also can’t continue to absorb the cost of caring for uninsured Americans the way we do — at the emergency room door.
That’s the dirty secret of the current system. The other is the fiscal black hole we’ve created by putting middlemen’s profits ahead of affordable preventive health care and coverage working Americans could have with a modest public subsidy, a la CHIP.
Anyone who worries about the cost of finding a new way needs to consider this: We’ll spend $8,000 per person on health care this year. The French with their single-payer system? $5,000 per person.
Prevention or profit?
France’s system, as with Canada’s, has its own problems — particularly rising costs. But both spend their money more intelligently — at the front end of the health care drama.
We use our money in the most ill-advised fashion, sandbagging it in a dance of individual and collective false economy. We wait until catastrophe forces our hands.
It’s very much open to question whether Obama’s hybrid approach based on preventive care can work in the face of an entrenched system based on profit.
Unfortunately, to a vast number of Americans the specter of 45 million without health insurance is of no concern. They have health plans. They can meet the deductible.
Thinking of the poolside think-tankers reminds me of the late Eddie Chiles, who owned the Texas Rangers before a certain U.S. president-to-be got a minority share.
Chiles’ oil-services company had a slogan: “If you don’t have an oil well, get one.”
If you don’t have a four-star swimming pool, get one.
If you don’t have health insurance, get some.
Pass the suntan lotion.
John Young’s column appears Thursday and Sunday. E-mail: jyoung@wacotrib.com.







Comments
By Bardo
Jun 20, 2009 7:54 AM | Link to this
John,
Is your departure related to the fact that Friends of Baylor has bought the Trib?
By Mark
Jun 19, 2009 12:36 AM | Link to this
John you forgot to break down the numbers on the 45 million of unisured. How many are illegal and how many are between the age 18 and 25 and rarely need to go to the doctor and choose not get health insurance at thier jobs and also the millions who know they can go to the emergancy room to be seen for anything ailing them and the hospital can not turn them away.So John out of the 300 million people. 255 million have insurance and I beleave I read 85% are happy with thier coverage.So why does President I love a crisis Obama want to run it like he is running Govermant Motors And the biggest banks? I guess I will get my answers on ABC (All oBama Channel ) during the Obama infomercial. I am pretty sure MSDNC oh my bad MSNBC will have some kind of spin on it to make sound like a great plan that we have to pass now to fix this crisis. Don't you get tired of hearing the word crisis being used every time by the President. Would hurt to say something good about America sometimes.This is still a great country and still will be after his four years are up .
By anonymous
Jun 18, 2009 12:09 PM | Link to this
I am glad you brought up the sun tan lotion. Obama needs to appoint a skin cancer czar so we can get some rules and regulations on sunscreen use and get this problem under CONTROL of the government! LOL. And this has nothing whatsoever to do with racism or social class, so don't put a spin on it. No reply necessary.
Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.
Post a comment
*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.