Subscribe to Waco Trib XML RSS Feed E-Newsletter WacoTrib on your PDA
Register Now.  It's Free!  |  Log In
Classifieds
Wacotrib Cars
Real Estate
Employment
Merchandise
NATION
Waco crime | Photo / video | Neighbor | State | Nation | World | Weather | Archives
Bookmark and Share E-mail this page Print this page Most E-mailed/Most printed small medium large Type size

John Young: 'Conspiracy of silence' on sex ed



Thursday, February 26, 2009

Imagine if a study found that jaw-dropping numbers of Texas math students had no clue about multiplication.

SWAT teams of experts would be dispatched. Heads would roll. State-assigned campus masters would arrive by air, by sea, by pack mule.

We can’t have our children ignorant of multiplication.

That is, unless it’s human multiplication: ovum, sperm, menstruation, conception, contraception. Then . . .

We can afford to have children fully ignorant, except to be preached at about the evils of following the urges associated therewith.

Basically, that’s the state of sex education in Texas, according to a new study that painstakingly has gone through what schools are teaching children, and what they are not.

Texas State University health education professor David Wiley and assistant professor Kelly Wilson have prepared a “state of sex education” report for the Texas Freedom Network. Per its title, Just Say Don’t Know, it is scandalous. It also is no surprise.

More than nine of 10 Texas schools basically punt away sex education in favor of federally funded abstinence-only approaches. Said the researchers, too often abstinence-only is more of a dodge than a means of educating young people about basic biology.

Morality trumping health

“The most troubling thing is how adults have failed kids,” Wiley said in a phone interview. “This is an adult problem. We have refused to address this as a public health matter. Instead, we’ve addressed it as a morality issue.”

While personal discretion — abstinence outside of marriage — should override all other issues, leaving things at that is a disservice to those we hope to educate.

Wiley has this challenge to abstinence-only disciples: “If you think what we’re doing is working really well, I’d like you to show us the data.”

The data: Texas has a teen pregnancy rate of 63 per thousand. The national average is 42 (2006 figures). Heckuva job.

This problem has two dimensions: (1) what Texas isn’t telling its children; (2) what it is. The problem with (2) is that a lot of it isn’t backed by facts. It simply fits the template of abstinence-only.

For instance, Wiley found many abstinence programs telling students that condoms fail 20 percent of the time. That’s false, if you’re talking about the actual failure rate of condoms. The real issue related to condom efficacy is user error, he said. That’s a big difference.

Regarding effective means of birth control and guarding against sexually transmitted disease, Wiley assailed a “conspiracy of silence.”

Yes, abstinence is the only safe sex. But what about those who aren’t going to abide by the abstinence pledge?

Lost in this whole debate, emotionally charged because of the issue of teen promiscuity, is the fact that sex education is about life skills and matters that come into play throughout one’s adulthood.

“I thought I was no longer capable of being surprised by the ignorance among our students,” Wiley wrote in the report. “Then last year a sincere male student asked aloud, ‘What is my risk for cervical cancer?’” Um, and when might this young man have learned the difference?

The Texas State researchers don’t just express condemnation about the bereft state of sex education. They have reasonable suggestions, too.

Topping the proposals is this: to have one certified health professional or educator on the health education councils that the state mandates for each district.

How any “health” council could whistle past issues of AIDS, STDs, contraception and the whole of holistic sex education is beyond me. But as Wiley points out, often people are dissuaded by administrators who don’t want controversy.

Texans should demand real biology education, meaning real sex education. Do the math and see that our kids have shown they can multiply — all too well.

John Young’s column appears Thursday and Sunday. E-mail: jyoung@wacotrib.com.

Comments

By parent

Feb 26, 2009 1:25 PM | Link to this

"The Texas State researchers donýt just express condemnation about the bereft state of sex education. They have reasonable suggestions, too."

Unfortunately, like reforming the TAKS testing system, this is another example of too many people in power ignoring the almost unanimous advice of professional educators.

By KDF

Feb 26, 2009 11:17 AM | Link to this

Firstly, it is shameful that we as adults have let our world sink to this level of depravity that our children have to learn these things before they even have time to mature. When biblical principals were held, the statistics of diseases and pregnacies were not nearly as high. Ah, but now the secular society jumps in and look where it has take us. Sure proves to me the biblical principle works better than the secular principle.

After writing that, I do agree our children must now learn these things early. My major disagreement is, do we teach them that God says to wait till marriage, or do we tell them only statistics that a secular world has brought upon us? <

By cheryl

Feb 26, 2009 10:40 AM | Link to this

even as an employee of the Tribune-Herald, i usually dont read the opinions page; however, this story grabbed my eye. i totally agree with you on this subject! i have 3 kids, at i home i stress the fact that sex is something that should be saved for marraige... BUT i never wanted them to feel like they couldnt come to me if they had other urges. so, as i told them it was something that should be shared by a man and his wife i also told them that i wanted them to be able to come to me with any questions if they ever felt like they were not going to wait. some would say that this way of teaching would send mixed signals to kids... i say... im keeping the line of communication open with my children. (i was pregnant and married at 16 and never felt comfortable talking with my mother about anything) i dont want my kids to feel that way! i have a 17 yr old boy that, unfortunately did not wait...but we did talk in great length before he actually made his decision. i also have a daughter who is 14; she and i talk about things that are going on with friends of hers whom are more advanced than she is. when she comes to me about things like that, i use that to my advantage to discuss whats going on, how she feels about it, and what she's thinking. the point is...that we discuss it! there are so many kids out there that dont have the opportunity to discuss these things with their parents, for one reason ot the other; they have to learn it somewhere; not just from their friends who are basically just as clueless as they are.

times have changed and our school systems should be changing as well. we are absolutely failing this generation, and future one's as well, if we dont get out of the mind set that abstinence only sex ed is working!!! and what about oral sex?? todays generation does not see this act as being sexual! that in itself is appauling! they have parties for that for goodness sakes.... its just so sad

Commenting is open from 8 a.m. to 5 p.m. M-F, except on Tuesday when it's open until 9 p.m.

Post a comment



Remember me?

You may use the following formatting:
Bold: **this text will be bolded** = this text will be bolded
Italic: *this text will be italic* = this text will be italic
Link: [text to be linked](http://www.wacotrib.com) = text to be linked



There will be a delay of up to 5 minutes before your comment appears.


*HTML not allowed in comments. Your e-mail address is required.

 
Waco Tribune-Herald Top Cars
Front Wheel Drive|Tires - Front Performance|Tires - Rear Performance|Alumin......(more)
Volkswagen Passat, 2003, 1.8L I4 20V MPFI DOHC Turbo, Midsize Car...(more)
Chevrolet Tahoe, 2005, 5.3L V8 16V MPFI OHV, Special Purpose Vehicle...(more)
Split Bench Seat|Driver Air Bag|AM/FM Stereo|Variable Speed Intermittent Wi......(more)
BMW 5 Series, 1997, 4.4L V8 OHV, Compact Car...(more)
Chevrolet Equinox, 2008, 3.4L V6 12V MPFI OHV, Special Purpose Vehicle...(more)
Chevrolet TrailBlazer EXT, 2004, 4.2L I6 24V MPFI DOHC, Special Purpose Vehicle...(more)
All Wheel Drive|Tires - Front Touring|Tires - Rear Touring|Aluminum Wheels|......(more)
Saturn VUE, 2006, 2.2L I4 16V MPFI DOHC, Special Purpose Vehicle...(more)
Power Passenger Mirror|Universal Garage Door Opener|Driver Illuminated Vani......(more)
-View All Top Cars-
-Place an Ad-
 

Wacotrib News | Wacotrib Weather | Sports | Living | Business News | Wacotrib Schools | Opinions | Baylor Football
Wacotrib Cars | Wacotrib Real Estate | Wacotrib Jobs | Classifieds | Sitemap

Copyright 2009 Waco Tribune-Herald. All rights reserved. - The Waco Tribune-Herald

By using this service, you accept the terms of our visitor agreement.  About our ads 
Registered site users, you may edit your profile.
Having trouble? Visit our help & FAQ.